(2005) Fantastic Four

as Leonard

(2022) Dead for a Dollar

as Martin Kidd

(2002) Live from Baghdad

as Richard Roth

(2012) Battleship

as Cal Zapata

Barron's Cove

as Lyle

(2011) The Future

as Jason

(2012) Lola Versus

as Henry

(2013) 42

as Ralph Branca

(2014) Magic in the Moonlight

as Brice

(2016) One More Time

as Tim

(2024) Nickel Boys

as Spencer

(2013) Redemption Trail

as David

(2015) The Big Short

as Porter Collins

(2008) The Violent Kind

as Frank

(2023) Downtown Owl

as Principal Valentine

(2025) A Big Bold Beautiful Journey

as ---

(2015) Ithaca

as Tom Spangler

(2014) The Angriest Man in Brooklyn

as Tommy Altmann

(2011) I'm Coming Over

as Buffalo

(2017) A Midsummer Night's Dream

as Lysander

(2018) You Can't Say No

as Miles

(2005) Everything's Gone Green

as William

(2000) Groove

as David Turner

(2018) Paper Year

as Noah Bearinger

(2017) Unicorn Store

as Gary

(2020) 10 Things We Should Do Before We Break Up

as Ben

(2003) Final Draft

as Marty

(2005) The Sailor's Girl

as ---

(2025) The Life of Chuck

as US Reporter

Cattywampus

as Max

(2020) The Stand

as Dr. Jim Ellis

(2002) American Dreams

as Pvt. Stan Silver

(2006) Ugly Betty

as Evan Grant

(2007) Pushing Daisies

as John Joseph Jacobs

(2006) The New Adventures of Old Christine

as Matthew Kimble

(2000) Gideon's Crossing

as Dr. Bruce Cherry

(2004) 5ive Days to Midnight

as Carl Axelrod

(2013) The Crazy Ones

as Andrew

(2021) Midnight Mass

as Father Paul Hill

(2022) Angelyne

as Rick Krause

(1999) Law & Order: Special Victims Unit

as David Morris

(2014) Fargo

as Larue Dollard

(2009) The Good Wife

as David LaGuardia

(2020) Monsterland

as Joe Keller

(2022) Gaslit

as Jeb Magruder

(2024) Manhunt

as Abraham Lincoln

(2021) Tell Me Your Secrets

as John

(2017) Legion

as Clark Debussy

(2024) Batman: Caped Crusader

as Batman / Bruce Wayne (voice)

(2012) The Newsroom

as Jerry Dantana

(2021) Cinema Toast

as ---