Dustin Hoffman

Captain Hook

Robin Williams

Peter Banning / Peter Pan

Julia Roberts

Tinkerbell

Bob Hoskins

Smee

Maggie Smith

Granny Wendy

Caroline Goodall

Moira

Charlie Korsmo

Jack

Amber Scott

Maggie

Laurel Cronin

Liza

Phil Collins

Inspector Good

Arthur Malet

Tootles

Isaiah Robinson

Pockets

Jasen Fisher

Ace

Dante Basco

Rufio

Raushan Hammond

Thud Butt

James Madio

Don't Ask

Thomas Tulak

Too Small

Alex Zuckerman

Latchboy

Ahmad Stoner

No Nap

Bogdan Georghe

Lost Boy

Adam McNatt

Lost Boy

René González Jr.

Additional Lost Boy

Brian Willis

Additional Lost Boy

Brett Willis

Additional Lost Boy

Ryan Francis

Young Peter

Max Hoffman

5-Year-Old Peter Pan

Kelly Rowan

Peter's Mother

Stephanie Furst

Mermaid

Shannon Marie Kies

Mermaid

Regina Russell Banali

Mermaid

Jewel Newlander Hubbard

Peter Pan in Play

Jeannine Renshaw

Drama Teacher

Rebecca Hoffman

Jane in Play

Jeannine Wagner

Pianist

Francesca Serrano

Lost Boy in Play

Kevin Gasca

Lost Boy in Play

Andre Bollinger

Lost Boy in Play

Lauren Friedler-Gow

Lost Boy in Play

Bryce Armstrong

Lost Boy in Play

Margie Takeda

Lost Boy in Play

Alyson Healing

Lost Boy in Play

Zoe Koehler

Lost Boy in Play

Scott Williamson

Coach

Wayne Aten

Umpire

Michael Hirshenson

Umpire

Jake Hoffman

Little League Player

Geoffrey Lower

Brad

Don S. Davis

Dr. Fields

Cameron Thor

Ron

Brad Blumenthal

Jim

Brenda Isaacs Booth

Secretary

Jan Cobler

Secretary

Ruth de Sosa

Secretary

Stuart White

Chauffeur

Gwyneth Paltrow

Young Wendy

Don McLeod

Mime / Shadow

Kim O'Kelley

Prostitute

Beverly Polcyn

Prostitute

Randi Cee

Prostitute

Mary Bond Davis

Prostitute

David Crosby

Tickles

Nick Tate

Noodler

Tony Burton

Bill Jukes

Glenn Close

Gutless

Nick Ullett

Pirate Jailer

Matthew Van Ginkel

Baby Peter Banning

Ray Tveden

Man in Stands

Kim Robillard

Toothless Cripple

Michael Runyard

Screaming Pirate

Gary Epper

Growling Pirate

Jeff Bornstein

Pirate (uncredited)

Carrie Fisher

Woman Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)

George Lucas

Man Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)

Jimmy Buffett

Shoe-Stealing Pirate (uncredited)