Richard Dreyfuss

Meyer Lansky

Illeana Douglas

Anna Lansky

Anthony LaPaglia

Charlie "Lucky" Luciano

Eric Roberts

Ben "Bugsy" Siegel

Beverly D'Angelo

Teddy Lansky

Yosef Carmon

Rabbi / Caretaker

Mosko Alkalai

Jewelry Shopkeeper

Fima Noveck

Hasid in Grodno

Joshua Praw

Eight-Year-Old Meyer Lansky

Jill Holden

Yetta Lansky

James Harper

Longy Zwillman

Octavia Spencer

Evelyn

Scott Rabinowitz

Zen Ben-Dov

Adam Hendershott

Irish Boy #2

Bernardo Hiller

Max Lansky

Brian Casey

Irish Boy #1

Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

Jake Lansky Ages 9-11

Jeff Perry

American Lawyer

Larry Moss

Benjamin Lansky

Matthew Settle

Bugsy Siegel Ages 17-26

Max Perlich

Meyer Lansky Ages 19-28

Ryan Merriman

Meyer Lansky Ages 12-14

Stanley DeSantis

Arnold Rothstein

Benjamin Kimball Smith

Irish Gang Leader

Anthony Medwetz

Benny Siegel - Age 11

Amit Alon

Boy Outside Jewelry Shop

Paul Sincoff

Charlie Luciano Ages 17-30

P.C. Frieberg

Old City Civilian

Bill Capizzi

Joe 'The Boss' Masseria

Eric Saiet

IRS Man #1

Michael Krawic

IRS Man #2

Brian Frank

Maranzano Deskman

Ron Gilbert

Salvatore Maranzano

David Selburg

Maranzano Bookkeeper

Lawrence Arancio

Buddy's Doctor

Nick Corello

Albert Anastasia

Tom La Grua

Frank Costello

Sal Landi

Joe Adonis

Dean Norris

Naval Captain

Randy Polk

Heavyset Man in Cinema

John Gavigan

Longshoreman

Robert Miano

Vito Genovese

Peggy Jo Jacobs

Virginia Hill

Scott Haven

Flamingo Surveyor

A.J. Tannen

Reporter at LOD Airport

Ron Pacheco

Paul Lansky Age 17

Tom Towles

Henchman at NYC Apartment

Mitchell Roche

Buddy Lansky Age 19

Kenneth Meseroll

FBI Agent at NYC Apartment

Maria Carmen

Conga Dancer

Peter Siragusa

Moe Dalitz

Tom Dreesen

Flamingo Emcee / Eddie Shum

Claudine Barros

Paraguay Stewardess

Angelo Pagán

Asunción Customs Official #1

Jeffrey Sharmat

Buddy Lansky Age 10

Devon Michael

Paul Lansky Age 8

Arnie Alpert

Asunción Customs Official #2

Francis Guinan

Senator Estes Kefauver

Bert Remsen

Senator Tobey

Ron Perkins

Moses Polakoff

Michael Townsend Wright

Jake Lansky

Bix Barnaba

Hallandale Lounge Maitre D'

Maura Vincent

Hallandale Lounge Waitress

Diva Haase

Hallandale Lounge Singer

Michelle Bonilla

Panama Stewardess

Eddie Driscoll

Super Club Maitre d'

Peter Dobson

Man at Supper Club

Raul Guterres

Cuban Revolutionary

Phil Reeves

FBI Agent on Jetliner

Susie Spear Purcell

Female Miami Reporter

Michael Steve Jones

Male Miami Reporter #1

Matthew Butcher

Male Miami Reporter #2

Larkin Campbell

Male Miami Reporter #3

Michael Barrett Caron

Miami Immigration Official #1

Joey Dee

Miami Immigration Official #2

Kathe Mazur

Miami Hospital Nurse

James Noah

Federal Judge

Lynne Marie Stewart

Waitress at Wolfie's

Maury Ginsberg

Uri Behar

Mickey Knox

Older Man at Wolfie's

Scott Brantley

Brazilian Air Passenger

Mário Lara

Panamanian

Douglas M. Nelson

Court Reporter (uncredited)