Vince Edwards

Sheriff Sam

Don Adams

The Old Cowhand / Host

Jill St. John

Molly

Zero Mostel

Heavy Harry

Lesley Ann Warren

Emmy Lou

Frankie Avalon

Stagecoach Driver

Carl Ballantine

Ringo

Cass Elliot

Mrs. James (as 'Mama' Cass Elliot)

Dale Evans

Dale

The First Edition

Themselves

George Gobel

Dingo

Sam Jaffe

Old Sam

George Kirby

Bartender

Casey Douglas Long

Dancer

Rob Reece

Gun Slinger

Kenny Rogers

Balladeer

Roy Rogers

Roy

Mike Settle

Balladeer

Terry Williams

Balladeer

Maria Pogee

Dancer (uncredited)