Zac Efron

Ted Bundy

Lily Collins

Liz Kendall

Kaya Scodelario

Carole Anne Boone

Jeffrey Donovan

Utah Defense Attorney John O'Connell

Angela Sarafyan

Joanna

Dylan Baker

Utah Prosecutor David Yocom

Brian Geraghty

Florida Public Defender Dan Dowd

Terry Kinney

Detective Mike Fisher

Haley Joel Osment

Liz's Co-Worker Jerry

James Hetfield

Officer Bob Hayward

Grace Victoria Cox

Carol Daronch

Jim Parsons

Florida Prosecutor Larry Simpson

John Malkovich

Judge Edward D. Cowart

Sydney Vollmer

Babysitter

Macie Carmosino

2 Yr Old Molly

Ava Inman

4 Yr Old Molly

Morgan Pyle

8 Yr Old Molly

Richard K. Jones

Interrogation Room Sheriff

Justin Inman

Police Lineup Suspect

Alan B. Jones

Utah Judge Stewart Hanson

Maya Berlinger

Concerned Library Co-Ed

Derek Snow

Security Guard

Leilani Barrett

Liz's Boss

Ryan Wesley Gilreath

Deputy Westerlund

Ken Strunk

Colorado Judge George Lohr

Jared Joplin

Colorado District Attorney Frank Tucker

Justin McCombs

Colorado Defense Attorney Jim Dumas

Joe Berlinger

Colorado Jailhouse Reporter

Brandon Trost

Colorado Jailhouse Cameraman

Tim Young

Colorado Jailhouse Boom Op

Torrie Wiggins

Woman w/Dog

Chris Petty

Officer David Lee

Kevin McClatchy

Sherriff Ken Katsaris

Paul Kulis

Visitation Room Guard

Michael Simkin

Florida Reporter

Tess Talbot

Florida Public Defender Margaret Good

David Myers Gregory

Bailiff Dave Watson

Ming Wang

Court Clerk Shirley Lewis

Sarah Berlinger

Bundy Groupie #1

Claire Sinofsky

Bundy Groupie #2

Caroline Hurwitz

Bundy Groupie #3

Savannah Rodin

Enchanted Girl

James Harper

Detective Chapman

Forba Shepherd

Louise Bundy

Barry Mulholland

Dr. Richard Souviron

Joey Boyd

Bribable Guard

Ally Sereda

Liz's Secretary

Grace Balbo

Teenage Molly

Amy Greene

Ted Bundy Victim

Chris Hahn

Utah Courthouse Bailiff

Rajiim A. Gross

Metro Justice Journalist (uncredited)

Calvin David Jones III

Utah Prisoner (uncredited)

James Siderits

Prisoner's Attorney (uncredited)

Bret Aaron Knower

Utah State Prison Guard (uncredited)

John E. Brownlee

Miami Prison Guard (uncredited)

Jerry Mullins

Utah State Prisoner (uncredited)