Sam Hennings

Benjamin Steed

Brenda Strong

Mary Ann Steed

Eric Johnson

Joshua Steed

Alexander Carroll

Nathan Steed

Tiffany Dupont

Lydia McBride

Brighton Hertford

Melissa Steed / Narrator

Kimberly Varadi

Becca Steed

Colin Ford

Matthew Steed

Kathryn Firago

Hannah McBride

Jim Grimshaw

Josiah McBride

Jonathan Scarfe

Joseph Smith

Sarah Darling

Emma Smith

Edward Albert

Martin Harris

Ryan Wood

Hyrum Smith

Jordan Rose Tarter

Sophronia Smith

Anne Sward

Lucy Mack Smith

Levi Larsen

Samuel Smith

Sara Jade Woodhouse

Will Murdock

Jonathan Quint

Mark Cooper

Phillip DeVona

David Murdock

Marcus Hester

Caleb Jackson

Emily Podleski

Jessica Roundy

Bill Crabb

Asa Phelps

Annie Abbott

Edith Gates

Wayne Grace

First Land Agent

Charles Howerton

Second Land Agent

Kevin Stillwell

First Man

Bruce Taylor

First Member

Sheri Mann Stewart

First Woman

Marc Macaulay

Land Speculator

Stephen Gentry

Second Man

Zane Miller

First Suitor

Joseph Wilkins

Second Member

Tom Turbiville

Teamster

Carey Jones

Third Man

James Van Harper

Wagon Master

Richie Dye

Clinton Roundy

Laura Whyte

Aunt Helen

Terry Haskell

First Troublemaker

Terry Londeree

Parson

Jarron Vosburg

Young Joseph

Thais Albert

Cousin Sabina

Bruce McKinnon

Preacher

William David Witt

Man on the bench

William J. Mode

Pipe smoking tavern patron (uncredited)