Carlos Alazraqui

Charlie Evans

Dana Barron

Kristy

Alfonso Freeman

Pastor Kennedy

Pam Grier

Zelda

Lou Diamond Phillips

Garrett

Ellen Albertini Dow

Natalie Shaw

Megan Ward

Michelle

William Brent

Additional Voices (voice, as Billy Unger)

Jacoby Shaddix

Thomas Walker

Victor Browne

Jack Chadway

Judea Cavoto

Abby Taylor

Lynda Reynoso

Maggie Walker

Rhett McKinney

Roger

William Van Noland

The Man

Laken Romine

Young Natalie

Christopher Michael Holley

Lieutenant Williams

Michael Alaimo

Father Adams

Michael Alaimo

Christina Genusu

Emily Frazier Klingensmith

Mother

Fred Pitts

Doctor

Susan Anderson

Receptionist

Damien Xavier Johnson

Dante

James Anthony Cotton

Marty Fitzpatrick

Mary Mackey

Hospital Administrator

Matthew Vlahakis

Bank Representative

Duane Schirmer

Book Store Manager

Peter Quartaroli

ER Doctor

Jen Rainin

ER Nurse (as Jennifer Rainin)

Christina A. Wood

ER Nurse #2 / Demon Mother

Michael Greggans

ER Doctor #2

Fred DeRuvo

Wedding Pastor

Karen Dahl

Real Estate Agent

Sarah Brown

Natalie's Mother

Emily Everhard

(voice) (as Emily Rose Everhard)

Christa Bella

Paparazzi (uncredited)

Johann Benét

Vince (uncredited)

Eric Bowen

Policeman (uncredited)

Nick Fenske

Marine Pallbearer (uncredited)

Ja'Cassia Haley

Child in Bookstore (uncredited)

Linda Joy Henry

Nurse (uncredited)

Emmalea Luna

Child in Bookstore (uncredited)

Moksha McPherrin

Isabella (uncredited)

Caon Mortenson

Child in Book Ttore (uncredited)

Jack Stahl

Policeman / Funeral Attendee (uncredited)