Gene Wilder

Avram

Harrison Ford

Tommy

Ramon Bieri

Mr. Jones

Val Bisoglio

Chief Gray Cloud

George DiCenzo

Darryl Diggs

Leo Fuchs

Chief Rabbi

Penny Peyser

Rosalie

William Smith

Matt Diggs

Jack Somack

Samuel Bender

Beege Barkette

Sarah Mindl

Shay Duffin

O'Leary

Walter Janovitz

Old Amish Man

Joe Kapp

Monterano

Clyde Kusatsu

Mr. Ping

Clifford A. Pellow

Mr. Daniels

Allan Rich

Mr. Bialik

Henry Rowland

1st Farmer (Amish Man)

Vincent Schiavelli

Brother Bruno

John Steadman

Booking Agent

Ian Wolfe

Father Joseph

Steffen Zacharias

Herschel Rosensheine

Eda Reiss Merin

Mrs. Bender

Kenny Selko

Little Boy

Warren Selko

Little Boy

John Bleifer

First Rabbi

Ben Kahlon

Rabbi

Michael Elias

Rabbi

Rolfe Sedan

Rabbi

Rusty Blitz

Rabbi

Sam Nudell

Rabbi

Gabriel Curtiz

Rabbi

Larry Gelman

Rabbi

Zachary Berger

Rabbi

Martin Garner

Rabbi

Herbert Mitchel

Black Man

David Bradley

Julius Rosensheine

Richard Dunham

Second Farmer (Amish Man)

Bret Briggs

Little Amish Boy

Brad Briggs

Little Amish Boy

Chip Frye

Teenage Boy

June Constable

Amish Wife

Jacques Hampton

Fisherman #1

Roy Kaye

Fisherman #2

Catherine Chase

Lady on Train

Linda Stearns

Mother

Heidi Stearns

Jane

Howard Gudmundson

Railroad Employee Applicant

Marty White

Railroad Employee Applicant

George Barrows

Ticket Purchaser

Gloria Hayes

Indian Maiden

Alex Romero

Wild Old Man

Robert Padilla

Medicine Man

Frank De Vol

Piano Player (Old Timer)

Alvin Greenman

Wedding Guest

Joe Massengale

Cowboy #1

Richard Kennedy

Cowboy #2

Dick Dickinson

Cowboy #3

Allen Keller

Cowboy #4

Tom Lillard

Sheriff

Karl Lukas

Bartender

Young Jue

Waiter

Christine Glazier

Dance Hall Girl

Hank Robinson

Croupier

Angelyne

Busty Lady (uncredited)